The Rising Cost of Car Insurance

The cost of car insurance has reached a new high, with the average policy being 20.3% more expensive than the previous year, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. This marks the largest one-year increase in insurance costs since 1976, as reported by Bloomberg.

In December, Americans paid an average of $780.28 for a 6-month policy.

Out of all the factors considered in the Consumer Price Index, which measures inflation, auto insurance has seen the highest increase. The index shows an overall inflation rate of 3.4% during the same period.

Find Out: The Cars with the Highest and Lowest Insurance Costs

Soaring Repair Costs

The main culprit behind this surge in insurance costs is the steep rise in repair expenses. A recent analysis by The New York Times revealed that the average cost of repairing a car after an accident has skyrocketed by 36% within just five years.

Modern cars are equipped with advanced technology, often featuring pricey sensors placed in vulnerable areas. For instance, smart cruise control systems rely on radar and lidar sensors positioned externally on the vehicle. Unfortunately, this leaves them prone to damage even in minor collisions.

Even a seemingly straightforward windshield replacement can now cost over $1,000 due to embedded sensors and built-in lenses for traffic-scanning cameras.

Don't Miss: Factors That Significantly Impact Your Auto Insurance Rates

Climate-Driven Disasters Also a Factor

A recent analysis by The Washington Post highlighted the significant impact of climate-related weather events. This is especially evident in hurricane-prone regions like Florida, where even prominent insurers like Farmers Insurance have made the difficult decision to withdraw entirely.

EVs Cost More to Repair

Electric vehicles (EVs) are steadily gaining traction on American roads, accounting for a growing percentage of new car purchases. Cox Automotive, the parent company of Kelley Blue Book, reports that last year, 7.6% of new cars bought in the US were EVs, up from 5.8% in 2022 and 3.2% in 2021.

Repairing EVs can be more expensive compared to gas-powered cars, with Tesla vehicles being particularly costly to fix. In fact, some studies have indicated that repair costs for other EV brands are only slightly higher than those for gas-powered vehicles. However, Teslas are so expensive to repair that insurers often consider even lightly damaged models as total losses.

The need for costly repairs has allegedly influenced Hertz's recent decision to divest a significant portion of its Tesla fleet. In response to these concerns, Hertz has introduced its own insurance program. Nevertheless, an insurance pool comprised solely of expensive-to-repair cars presents its own challenges.